Controller or battery issue

Nealh

Esteemed Pedelecer
Aug 7, 2014
19,991
8,173
60
West Sx RH
also, for speed to get back riding, would you recommend purchasing a battery post haste? I‘m still concerned that the battery operates sometime for 20 minutes before then having power loss but appreciate my knowledge is extremely limited.
Power loss even though you see 700w in PAS one may depend on heat build up in the battery and inclines you come across.
 

Nealh

Esteemed Pedelecer
Aug 7, 2014
19,991
8,173
60
West Sx RH
I semi understand/get the gist of what your saying and thank you once again. I will endeavour to get a readout whilst cycling and report back in due course.
with regards to the PAS vs w load in each PAS level. Is there a way I can reconfigure the controller in order to make best use of this? (In essence a current control setup?)
Usually speed type of controller can't be reconfigured for current control, the KT/Keunteng controllers are current control by default but they do have a setting to switch to speed control as well most users don't bother switching modes.
Though you do have the Intelligent lcd, whether it allows the Lishui to switch between the two modes I don't know. Do you know or have you tried to see if it has advanced settings you can get in to ?

The only other way is to buy a new controller and display set up.
My KT 22a gives me approx. PAS1 80w, PAS2 130w, PAS3 210w, PAS4 320w & PAS5 640w at 36v, if I use 48v I get 33% more watts.
 
Last edited:

Matt hignett

Pedelecer
Jun 3, 2020
26
0
Herts
Usually speed type of controller can't be reconfigured for current control, the KT/Keunteng controllers are current control by default but they do have a setting to switch to speed control as well most users don't bother switching modes.
Though you do have the Intelligent lcd, whether it allows the Lishui to switch between the two modes I don't know. Do you know or have you tried to see if it has advanced settings you can get in to ?

The only other way is to buy a new controller and display set up.
My KT 22a gives me approx. PAS1 80w, PAS2 130w, PAS3 210w, PAS4 320w & PAS5 640w at 36v, if I use 48v I get 33% more watts.
I’ve had a look through the advanced settings within the lcd, there is nothing that offers a mode switch from current to speed control. The only offering is wheel size and I would presume that is to do with configuring the km/h display an accurate read. The advanced setting menu isn’t very advanced in it‘s offerings.
with regards to swapping over to a KT/keunteng controller and screen setup, will they work harmoniously with the rear wheel and battery I have? Where can I purchase if so from the UK? I think long term, this is probably a better idea for battery life/longevity and to use assist Levels dependant on the terrain I am on.

Is swapping out to a KT/keunteng controller easy to wire up?

thank you in advance! So helpful and humbled by your assistance.
 

Nealh

Esteemed Pedelecer
Aug 7, 2014
19,991
8,173
60
West Sx RH
With a KT you will have to buy the lcd as well for it to be compatible.
As with any controller the connectors might be different for PAS, throttle or brakes. It might entail fitting new conenctors or changing the sequence the wires are in, to be sure everything fits it is easier to but the new parts as required so it is simply plug and play.

Your motor connector if it is Julet 8 or 9 pin then yes will be compatible as regard to your battery it might work in PAS 1 or 2 but think it is pretty much knackered that said the lower current demand may make it work for very low power use.
 
Last edited:

Nealh

Esteemed Pedelecer
Aug 7, 2014
19,991
8,173
60
West Sx RH
UK resellers ask to much for a controller and lcd as well as not selling peripherals if you need them so it is better buying direct from a good reliable China vendor.
This one I can highly recommend with everything in one place.
Every thing you need is on the same page by selecting the items from the drop down boxes, before you buy check back here so we can see you have all the items you will need also you can check your various connectors to see if any match to save buying items you don't need.
On top of the final price inc courier delivery you will have to pay a small duty & handling fee of about £18 -£22 payble to the courier/DHL before they deliver it from the UK depot, all in it will not be no more expensive then from a UK seller who mark them up quite a bit and most only sell the controller and LCD.
 

Nealh

Esteemed Pedelecer
Aug 7, 2014
19,991
8,173
60
West Sx RH
This very recent thread offers the same advice and the upgrade is similar to yours with a speed controller. The KT is the most commonly available after market electronics to buy for an upgrade and the most user friendly most give little issue and most issues tend to be incorrect installation by the end user.
If you look around yo will find cheaper systems but they aren't a patch on the KT's.
 

Matt hignett

Pedelecer
Jun 3, 2020
26
0
Herts
UK resellers ask to much for a controller and lcd as well as not selling peripherals if you need them so it is better buying direct from a good reliable China vendor.
This one I can highly recommend with everything in one place.
Every thing you need is on the same page by selecting the items from the drop down boxes, before you buy check back here so we can see you have all the items you will need also you can check your various connectors to see if any match to save buying items you don't need.
On top of the final price inc courier delivery you will have to pay a small duty & handling fee of about £18 -£22 payble to the courier/DHL before they deliver it from the UK depot, all in it will not be no more expensive then from a UK seller who mark them up quite a bit and most only sell the controller and LCD.
Thanks ever so much! I will spec up a controller etc this coming weekend. Either way, it appears that you expect the battery is the current issue with the setup I currently have on the bike?

So with this in mind, first thing is to replace the battery like for like. I just don’t want to pay for a new battery and it not solve the current issue and then pay for a KT controller and display to then have to buy another battery Down the line. It would make more sense to buy a full conversion ‘kit’ and jump to 48v/1000w to gain addition range. My current plan was to buy an additional battery for longer rides with friends.

also, is there any way of learning more around the setup/installation/terminology?articles/posts/etc. You’ve been such a help and really knowledgable, I’d love to learn more to understand for future reference.

thanks as ever
 

Benjahmin

Esteemed Pedelecer
Nov 10, 2014
2,460
1,675
69
West Wales
Hi Matt,
Been reading this with interest, that and doing 5 different installations is the way I've learnt. Each one throws up it's own curiosities.
On the battery, it does sound like yours is well on it's way out. If you put a new battery on the existing controller it will work but be under the stress of constant 700w demand. This is a nominal current draw of 20A, so a new battery would, ideally, be capable of delivering 1.5 times this as a maximum, in order to minimise stress on your new battery. Yosepower have been a good supplier for me - shipping from a German wharehouse there was no duty to pay.

Think I might do it the other way round, change controller/display set up, get it all running nicely, then source a new battery.

I have an Ezee hub and this is speed control, so I run two batteries in parrallel to feed it. It's not subtle but it does get me round the Welsh hills. Here's the odd thing (mathmatically at least). Pas 2 gives me around 11-12mph on the flat. Pas3 will give me 14-15mph on the flat. So on a given journey (let's say 10 miles), as the system always runs at max current, then I will use less battery in pas3 than I will in pas2 as the journey takes less time. I KNOW, bonkers right?
In practice (I've done the same journeys in different settings) the best that can be said is that it doesn't seem to use more capacity in the higher setting.
 

Nealh

Esteemed Pedelecer
Aug 7, 2014
19,991
8,173
60
West Sx RH
The slower speed wiil pull more torque and current longer, the higher speed is near the cut off if legal so as the speed rises the current backs off.

The suggested 1000w kit is and probably will not feel as good as the current hub motor as the motor will be a D/D drive hub and not ideal for slow speed or inclines unless one highly specs the electronics at a greater cost, power comes with a price.
Ideally you will need to look for a more substantial controller 30- 40a out put and then a an ever costly battery able to out put an the 40a continuous using cells capable of a much higher discharge when in parallel so that they are not stressed.

All you can do is research and read, the Endless sphere forum in the US is a massive data base of info once you find your way around the massive thread index. For any powerful hub/motor the battery is key which means cost.
 

Nealh

Esteemed Pedelecer
Aug 7, 2014
19,991
8,173
60
West Sx RH
I agree with Ben a new controller set up is needed before anew battery with the current speed controller set up, as you have seen lower powered motors can take more current watts and 250w hubs can take up to about 1000w if you don't abuse the higher wattage all the time and just save it for temporary use.

You have to set out your goals cost of buying and funding said kit, extra cost for a high spec heavier battery and the extra weight of D/D hub these typically weigh about 5 - 6kg. The battery and hub will alone add a min of 3kg of weight to the hand bike, dead weight uses up more battery energy.
 

Nealh

Esteemed Pedelecer
Aug 7, 2014
19,991
8,173
60
West Sx RH
Matt your current hub motor looks like a 500w geared hub probably a Bafang from the glimpse in the pic of it, a 48v 1000w D/D hub won't be an improvement tbh over it.

Some more pics of it and any writing on the motor would be useful then we can see what it's speed rating might be.

The 500w if a geared hub at least it is a more user friendly motor being that if you had to it will be rideable with low gearing should you have a power issue as you have at the mo, a D/D hub would be dead in the water. The 500w hub will easily take a 30a controller but again you will need a very good battery at that current.
Your current battery 13000mah/13ah just hasn't got the required continuous discharge rate to cope with the 22a continuous current it is seeing at the moment, as I mentioned earlier I am 99% certain it is using low current power 5a Samsung 26F 2600mah cells which are now past it.
I had the same cells in a pair of batteries used on a 250w hub kit delivering 17a max current and they lost about 25% range over a 18 - 24 month period as I too would max out the speed and current, my max current use would have been about 450 - 500w so less then your 700w you are seeing. My batteries never saw voltage self discharge after charging they did remain in a usable fair condition unlike yours which are failing as the max charge voltage and self discharge of < 41v is showing.
 

Matt hignett

Pedelecer
Jun 3, 2020
26
0
Herts
Firstly to all, thank you for the information and advice.

As I could source a battery rather quickly and this one appears to be on its way out, it seems like a ‘quick fix’ would be to get another battery for my current setup. I could have the battery delivered within a few days allowing me to get out and use my handbike with the knowledge that I’m not going to have a breakdown 20km away from home in a woodland/field. To note, this is a temporary fix for a month or two with a reconditioned battery being available for circa £100.

Although the voltage meter hasn’t yet arrived (Purchased from eBay), I have a volt display on the lcd screen on my current setup. So with a little faith I went out on a trail I know this morning and crossed my fingers for some luck. To my surprise I made it on the 19km route with no power loss. I spent the time monitoring the readout and noticed a drop from 42v to 38v after the hour long ride. At times under load it dropped to 36v near the end of the ride going up an incline. I fully expected it to die on me but it Voltage drop I would presume highlights the battery condition not being great. Moreso the lcd screen indicated 3/5 bars of battery left with the battery indicator sub menu on the screen stating 60% at the end of the ride. This has always been around the amount of battery use on this particular route. I also paid attention to the amount of watts I was using upon pulling off, on various small gradients and when cruising along. At no time did it constantly draw 700w! Cruising was circa 100-300w and inclined was a variation up to around 550w. the gradients weren’t significant on this route.

So my beginners understanding is the drop in voltage indicates the battery isn’t healthy and needs resolving. The long term solution is to change from a speed control to a current control Setup. But for now, getting a replacement battery is the “quick fix” whilst speccing up a new controller etc.... yes/no/Matt your talking Rubbish.
 

Matt hignett

Pedelecer
Jun 3, 2020
26
0
Herts
Matt your current hub motor looks like a 500w geared hub probably a Bafang from the glimpse in the pic of it, a 48v 1000w D/D hub won't be an improvement tbh over it.

Some more pics of it and any writing on the motor would be useful then we can see what it's speed rating might be.

The 500w if a geared hub at least it is a more user friendly motor being that if you had to it will be rideable with low gearing should you have a power issue as you have at the mo, a D/D hub would be dead in the water. The 500w hub will easily take a 30a controller but again you will need a very good battery at that current.
Your current battery 13000mah/13ah just hasn't got the required continuous discharge rate to cope with the 22a continuous current it is seeing at the moment, as I mentioned earlier I am 99% certain it is using low current power 5a Samsung 26F 2600mah cells which are now past it.
I had the same cells in a pair of batteries used on a 250w hub kit delivering 17a max current and they lost about 25% range over a 18 - 24 month period as I too would max out the speed and current, my max current use would have been about 450 - 500w so less then your 700w you are seeing. My batteries never saw voltage self discharge after charging they did remain in a usable fair condition unlike yours which are failing as the max charge voltage and self discharge of < 41v is showing.
the only writing/info on the hub is on the attached photos. I’m more than happy to take more from other angles is required?
 

Attachments

Matt hignett

Pedelecer
Jun 3, 2020
26
0
Herts
The slower speed wiil pull more torque and current longer, the higher speed is near the cut off if legal so as the speed rises the current backs off.

The suggested 1000w kit is and probably will not feel as good as the current hub motor as the motor will be a D/D drive hub and not ideal for slow speed or inclines unless one highly specs the electronics at a greater cost, power comes with a price.
Ideally you will need to look for a more substantial controller 30- 40a out put and then a an ever costly battery able to out put an the 40a continuous using cells capable of a much higher discharge when in parallel so that they are not stressed.

All you can do is research and read, the Endless sphere forum in the US is a massive data base of info once you find your way around the massive thread index. For any powerful hub/motor the battery is key which means cost.
Thank you for the information, my feeling is to stick with the current hub, it gets a bit noisy after half an hour but would be a,lot easier than trying to source a 24” hub/wheel without having to get a hub laced to a rim. The idea of going for a substantial controller and costly battery doesn’t rally appeal. My current setup has been awesome for 3 years and really I just want the reliability and effectiveness of what I have. If by changing the controller and screen for a KT setup I get the advantage of longevity in battery health and PAS levels then I think that’s a fair gain for the cost. Would you agree?
 

Matt hignett

Pedelecer
Jun 3, 2020
26
0
Herts
Hi Matt,
Been reading this with interest, that and doing 5 different installations is the way I've learnt. Each one throws up it's own curiosities.
On the battery, it does sound like yours is well on it's way out. If you put a new battery on the existing controller it will work but be under the stress of constant 700w demand. This is a nominal current draw of 20A, so a new battery would, ideally, be capable of delivering 1.5 times this as a maximum, in order to minimise stress on your new battery. Yosepower have been a good supplier for me - shipping from a German wharehouse there was no duty to pay.

Think I might do it the other way round, change controller/display set up, get it all running nicely, then source a new battery.

I have an Ezee hub and this is speed control, so I run two batteries in parrallel to feed it. It's not subtle but it does get me round the Welsh hills. Here's the odd thing (mathmatically at least). Pas 2 gives me around 11-12mph on the flat. Pas3 will give me 14-15mph on the flat. So on a given journey (let's say 10 miles), as the system always runs at max current, then I will use less battery in pas3 than I will in pas2 as the journey takes less time. I KNOW, bonkers right?
In practice (I've done the same journeys in different settings) the best that can be said is that it doesn't seem to use more capacity in the higher setting.
Hi Ben,

thank you for pitching in and assisting. I find the dual battery setup fascinating and that PAS3 is more economical, it’s definitely what I would like to to long term. especially if it uses less battery which means the range I can travel will go up! Also thank you for the info on the battery supplier, I’m sure this will come in handy :)
 

Nealh

Esteemed Pedelecer
Aug 7, 2014
19,991
8,173
60
West Sx RH
Going by what you say about the wattage output today then it sounds like I might be wrong and you may have a current controller, the brand is Lishui. Though I'm surprised as you said in a previous post you saw 700w in PAS 1 which made me think it was a speed controller.

The hub for looks like a Bafang one or if not a very good clone, the motor noise might be down to lack of grease inside which is easy to remedy.
Does the noise sound mechanical or electrical ?

A 500w geared hub as you have will take 25/30a so will be more user friendly and cos effective then a D/D hub.
 

Matt hignett

Pedelecer
Jun 3, 2020
26
0
Herts
Going by what you say about the wattage output today then it sounds like I might be wrong and you may have a current controller, the brand is Lishui. Though I'm surprised as you said in a previous post you saw 700w in PAS 1 which made me think it was a speed controller.

The hub for looks like a Bafang one or if not a very good clone, the motor noise might be down to lack of grease inside which is easy to remedy.
Does the noise sound mechanical or electrical ?

A 500w geared hub as you have will take 25/30a so will be more user friendly and cos effective then a D/D hub.
I have no clue if it is current or speeed controller. I have seen it at 700w in PAS1 when going up steep inclines for certain. However it doesn’t typically go much last 300w when in false flats or general use.
the motor noise is sounds more mechanical, typically after 30minutes use. How do I regrease inside? And with regards to the vw,Stev drop off, would you predict it’s the battery and worthies purchasing a replacement as per my other message?

I so grateful for your assistance, to everyone‘s! Definitely will be reading More about this throughout the bday. It’s fast becoming a big interest of mine!
 

Nealh

Esteemed Pedelecer
Aug 7, 2014
19,991
8,173
60
West Sx RH
My KT's even the 25a one only gives me about 150/160w max in PAS 1 (even climbing) , so to see 700w I would in my eyes say it is speed control.
I had/have an LSW on the Bafang BPM motor wheel kit, though no W output on the screen each PAS level of five I could feel the different current in each one.

To open them it is easier with the wheel removed , if need be take pics of the process as you go along.
On the LHS you need to undo the inner axle nut/bearing seal retainer, there should be a washer and a clear rubber seal behind it protecting the sealed pressed in bearing.
Flip it over to the RHS and if need be remove the gears, undo the six outer cover plate screws, the insides should then separate and be able to remove as one (sometimes you may have to tap the LHS axle with a rubber mallet or wooden block).

The planetary gears and casing gearing should be accessible now and whether or not greasing is needed, if dried or contaminated clean it out and replace with grease (I use Dark Grey Castrol Moly grease and a good handful or a copious slathering ) make sure the grease isn't petroleum based other wise the nylon gears will become damaged/distorted.
Whilst cleaning up inspect the general condition of said planetary nylon gear condition, it they look warn or chewed replace them, Individual gears can be replaced (you will have to measure them , teeth count , shaft size and o/a outer size, thickness etc,etc) as they are usually held by a circlip but I would change all three if you have to change any.

Whilst also a part axle will have a central bearing check this for hand rotation roughness/play and replace if so also check the LHS side end case bearing .
The bearing will lever off the axle using opposing levers as you go around the bearing, the end case one with drive out with a suitable drift like a piece of tube or better still a suitable size socket for a ratchet socket set.
 

Matt hignett

Pedelecer
Jun 3, 2020
26
0
Herts
My KT's even the 25a one only gives me about 150/160w max in PAS 1 (even climbing) , so to see 700w I would in my eyes say it is speed control.
I had/have an LSW on the Bafang BPM motor wheel kit, though no W output on the screen each PAS level of five I could feel the different current in each one.

To open them it is easier with the wheel removed , if need be take pics of the process as you go along.
On the LHS you need to undo the inner axle nut/bearing seal retainer, there should be a washer and a clear rubber seal behind it protecting the sealed pressed in bearing.
Flip it over to the RHS and if need be remove the gears, undo the six outer cover plate screws, the insides should then separate and be able to remove as one (sometimes you may have to tap the LHS axle with a rubber mallet or wooden block).

The planetary gears and casing gearing should be accessible now and whether or not greasing is needed, if dried or contaminated clean it out and replace with grease (I use Dark Grey Castrol Moly grease and a good handful or a copious slathering ) make sure the grease isn't petroleum based other wise the nylon gears will become damaged/distorted.
Whilst cleaning up inspect the general condition of said planetary nylon gear condition, it they look warn or chewed replace them, Individual gears can be replaced (you will have to measure them , teeth count , shaft size and o/a outer size, thickness etc,etc) as they are usually held by a circlip but I would change all three if you have to change any.

Whilst also a part axle will have a central bearing check this for hand rotation roughness/play and replace if so also check the LHS side end case bearing .
The bearing will lever off the axle using opposing levers as you go around the bearing, the end case one with drive out with a suitable drift like a piece of tube or better still a suitable size socket for a ratchet socket set.
Thanks for the info, I’ll order some appropriate grease and follow the instructions (Then report back on it). I cannot thank you enough with regards to all the advice and£ information you’ve given me. I’ll be ordering a battery first thing Monday and then spec a new controller/display. My Feeling is that the New battery will rectify the situation but isn’t a long term solution. The battery is 3 years old however having a current control setup with KT controller seems the most reliable route to go. I’ll stick around the 750w setup as it provide good levels of assist vs price. I’d hopefully run two batteries with this new setup to so I can increase range. Does this seem like a good solution overall (short and long term solutions)?

thanks as ever
 

Nealh

Esteemed Pedelecer
Aug 7, 2014
19,991
8,173
60
West Sx RH
For the new battery spec one that is 30a contiuous so it can cope with demand of the old controller if you are going to still use it in the short term.
With two batteries the best use for them is to parallel them together by making up a parallel lead, then they act as one and will discharge uniformly. They will still be 36v or 48v but the capacity and discharge current increases by adding each to the other so for example, if you had 25 & 30a discharge batteries in P they would have a 55a discharge rate and would run with less stress on the cells. Capacity wise say a 13ah and 15ah they will run as a 28ah battery so will hold a higher voltage level for longer and overall voltage sag will be less.

The critical bit when paralleling batteries is they must be disconnected and charged separately as each will have it's own BMS, when connecting them in parallel they must be at near the same voltage charge. That means they should ideally be within 0.025v so as to reduce voltage equalisation/heat exchange, the heat that can be generated is immense. The wider the voltage difference current will flow in nano seconds, extreme heat is caused by current flow from widely varying voltages when connected.