Well done you, Mandy! If you do start up again I would urge you to forget setting a low price, but instead set a price that reflects the many hours you put in to making them - and that difficult-to-cost additive - your unique skill!.
Making your own stuff to sell is just about the greatest thing you can do; there are no copies; they're unique - so set the price accordingly. For instance if you want a bicycle frame by a top frame builder then the actual tubes, brazing and paint only comes to a small amount, the hundreds and hundreds of pounds added to that cost reflect the frame builder's skill in building a quality frame and not his artistic paint job on the frame; the frame alone for my Thorn Audax will set you back £1100.00 just for the frame! You could of course obtain a high quality frame from a lesser known frame builder of equal durability for £350 or so - but it wouldn't be a Thorn, (I bought mine secondhand).
So quit treating those Unicorns as objects of little intrinsic value and FACTOR IN YOUR SKILL-SET INTO THE PRICE! If they don't sell then you'll know - but unless you market them according to your craft skill and prizewinning awards you'll never know. I wonder how many of your buyers unbeknownst to you sell them on for double as: unique hand made objects d'art?
No wonder you gave up making them - you're not charging enough to make it worthwhile to continue. Start by doubling the price - and I dare you to craft an extra special 'Thorn' Unicorn to retail for £1,000. (Well you did say you'd rather keep them, but you never know you might sell it).
Thank you Danny and very much appreciated
I do know what you mean about starting the price too low as always started mine at £9.99 to pull in the bids because some artists would start too high and didn't attract so many bids. But my goodness when I refresh that page at an end of an auction in the last couple of minutes the price just soured and I actually felt very humbled by that.
When I have revamped my site I may place a couple on there at a price and see how it goes? After all I won't mind hanging on to them a little longer

.
I have been asked many times for commisions for the same of prior work but won't do them because I feel that I would be obliged to re-create exactly the same and it doesn't work that way, lol
I don't think I will ever make a living from it as I am a terrible perfectionist and also have to be in the mood
I'm not saying my work is perfect but the finishing, ie: using fine sand paper to remove any slight inperfections on the surface of the clay under a magnifying glass maybe going to the extreme! as I know that other artists maybe will not go to so much trouble, lol.
I was on the up when I took a break as when I started out they went for £5 or £10 but were rubbish then if I'm honest but I kept at it and got so much better that my family ceased taking the mick and took me seriously
You are completely right about nothing like making your own stuff to sell and it never ceases to amaze me that people want them.
I am determined to get back to it and it was really only due to a complete career change that I stopped. Now I'm settled I am ready.
Thanks for your support
Mandy