OK thanks, that is reassuring. Some of the other failures I read about could possibly be explained by overheating or some other excuse but in this case I couldn't see any good reason.
Has anyone experienced controller failures after zooming downhill?
Someone on endless-sphere claimed:
"...One note on the [Tongxin] controllers, they are vulunerable to high levels of back EMF. If you go down a steep hill, the voltage generated by the motor will burn up the mosfets, I suspect because the internal diodes are conducting. The work around is to add some protection diodes on the three motor leads, to GND and Batt+."
An extra 6 diodes shouldn't add much cost so maybe Tongxin already do this on more recent controllers.